Westchester County Real Estate: Buyer and Seller Advice

Westchester County Real Estate: Buyer and Seller Advice

What makes a great real estate agent in Westchester County? How should homeowners price and market their properties, and what should buyers know about today's housing and mortgage markets?

In the first episode of the NestEdge Realty Podcast, Matthew Gluck and Jamie Fosgate discuss buying and selling homes in Westchester County, including Chappaqua, Briarcliff Manor, Armonk, Scarsdale, and Croton-on-Hudson.

They share practical advice on selecting a buyer's agent, pricing homes correctly, professional real estate photography, attracting motivated buyers, and understanding current mortgage conditions.

The conversation also explores what differentiates NestEdge Realty's hands-on approach, including personally attending property showings rather than relying on lockboxes.

Choosing the Right Buyer's Agent in Westchester County

Explain why buyers should look for local expertise, responsiveness, personal attendance at showings, and proactive property searches rather than relying exclusively on automated MLS notifications.

Pricing Your Westchester Home Correctly

Discuss why the initial asking price is critical and how pricing affects buyer interest, showing activity, and the likelihood of receiving competitive offers.

Why Professional Photography and the Cover Photo Matter

Explain how the first photograph buyers see online can determine whether they investigate a listing further or skip it entirely.

What Makes NestEdge Realty Different?

Highlight our hands-on approach to representing buyers and sellers, including personally attending showings, explaining property features, and actively marketing listings.

Are Open Houses Necessary to Sell a Home?

Discuss our perspective that motivated, high-intent buyers frequently schedule private appointments and why sellers should prioritize accommodating qualified buyers.

Westchester County Real Estate Market Conditions

Cover the local market discussion involving Chappaqua, Briarcliff Manor, Armonk, Scarsdale, and Croton-on-Hudson.

Mortgage Rates and Home Financing

Summarize the discussion about mortgage rates, adjustable-rate mortgages, comparing financing options, and the challenges of timing the housing market.

Please write these sections in natural, informative language, reflecting what was actually discussed in the episode rather than adding unsupported market statistics.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How do I choose the best buyer's agent in Westchester County, NY?
  2. What is the most important factor when pricing a home for sale?
  3. How important are professional photographs when selling a house?
  4. Do sellers need to hold open houses in Westchester County?
  5. Why should a listing agent attend property showings?
  6. Should homebuyers wait for mortgage rates to decrease?

Transcript

Matthew Gluck

All right, welcome to the NestEdge Realty podcast, number one — numero uno — where we will attempt to answer your Westchester County real estate questions, for new buyers, sellers, and people looking to relocate. I am Matthew Gluck, CEO and founder of NestEdge Realty.

Jamie Fosgate

And we have Jamie Fosgate — our top salesman, I guess. I don't know if I have any other title, but I'll go with that for now.

Matthew Gluck

Nice to start a podcast. Having started in 2017, we're in year nine of our business — next year will be lucky ten. We've learned an awful lot up until this point, so I think there's a lot for us to share, a lot for us to give to current clients, future clients. How many agents are we up to now?

Jamie Fosgate

We teeter between the 13 and 16 mark — you've got to get that roster exactly right, it's never going to be perfect. What I love about the team right now is we have people who run the gamut and can do different things. We have one person who knows every street in Westchester County, every town, what it's about, what the feel is, and we have agents who know what it was like back in the day. We run the age gamut, young to old. We also have agents in different pockets — Matt lives in Chappaqua, I'm in Croton, we have people in Scarsdale — so we get that pocket of expertise.

Matthew Gluck

I'd agree. And we're also part of East Coast Capital as mortgage brokers — Jamie and I have taken that on, been doing it over a year now, something like 10 or 15 deals so far. It's almost like picking right now to become a Jets fan — we have seven-and-a-half-percent mortgage rates, what a time to come in. But we'll learn while it's slow, and eventually when it picks up we'll get rates level.

Mortgage rates and home financing

Jamie Fosgate

It's amazing the number of buyers Matt and I had in the county in 2021–22 who, if they had private client relationships at banks, locked in under 3%. I'm at 3% on my mortgage — those people are going to be entrenched in their house and their mortgage for a long time. In the last 18 months the people we've put into homes, we're going to keep those relationships, because there are refis coming down the road, no question. One trend right now: if you look at the stats from the last two weeks, it's the highest-ever percentage of people taking adjustable-rate mortgages. That's a sign of the environment we're in.

Matthew Gluck

I've run into that with my own clients — they're running to the ARMs, and they've got to be careful with adjustable rates, because I don't know how much the banks are explaining about those loans. No one knows where this is going — we don't know what some of the policies coming in might or might not do to the bond market, which is closely tied to mortgage rates. I get clients all the time who ask how they're supposed to know what mortgage rates will do day to day. It's easy — pull up the 10-year yield. If the yield's coming down, mortgage rates are probably coming down; if the yield's going up, rates are probably going up. Clients who get into contract and have a float-down on their mortgage are watching that 10-year bond every day. There's a misconception that the Fed cutting or raising interest rates directly affects the mortgage market — it really doesn't. If it affects the 10-year bond, it affects mortgages; otherwise it doesn't.

I also get the "I'm seeing rates at 6%" text all the time. What people fail to realize is everyone's different — your down payment, the type of house, the total loan. If you're seeing a 6% fixed quote, check the fine print, because you might be paying points. It's hard to compare apples to apples with houses, but with mortgages it's actually easy to put two quotes side by side — take your two quote sheets and run them through an AI tool and ask what the real differences are. Back in the day you didn't have that; a novice might miss those points, but now you have the tools at your disposal to see, at the end of the day, am I paying more for loan A or loan B.

Jamie Fosgate

I have buyers who tell me they're going to wait for rates to drop, and I laugh at that, because no one knows. And if you're waiting for the perfect time — we're in Westchester, New York, not Topeka, Kansas, not Ohio. We're in a very competitive market. Sometimes the best time to buy is an uncomfortable time to buy, because if and when rates do drop, you're not the only person waiting for that — everybody else jumps in too, and then the price of the home shoots up. Sometimes the best time to buy is when you're most uncomfortable: rates are higher, but there's less competition for that house. And when the rate drops, you can go refi — but go get the house first.

Matthew Gluck

That's the way to build wealth. I'm a big stock-market guy, almost to the point of addiction — the thing I've learned investing in stocks is the only time you want to buy a stock is when people don't want them, and the only time to sell is when people are buying. That same idea applies to real estate. You can't time the real estate market.

Jamie Fosgate

No — you can time your life. Make the move when it's right for your life, when you find the right house. I've had clients find the right house, stay on the sidelines thinking the price will come down, and it's only gone up. I have clients from five years ago still waiting, and it's cost them hundreds of thousands of dollars waiting for the right house at the right price that's just never going to happen.

Choosing the right buyer's agent

Matthew Gluck

How does a client find the right house? You've sold more houses than any of my agents — how does your typical client zero in on the correct house?

Jamie Fosgate

They first come to the table with what they think they want. It's funny to write those things down for clients and show them afterward what we actually got into — because what you think you want looking on Zillow with your spouse ("we want this, that's really important") changes once you actually go see things, walk the neighborhoods, see the neighbors. What becomes important happens through the showing process. I think it takes seven to ten showings for a client to truly start to say, "I think I know what I want." From that point on we can really zero in, and once we see the one, we know it's the one — because we've eliminated what's not that important and included what's actually important once the rubber meets the road.

Matthew Gluck

The thing I tell new clients most often: seeing things you don't like is just as important as seeing things you think you love. There's no wasted time. Every reaction is a data point telling me what this client is actually looking for — and it's my job to find houses that are off the MLS, off-market, that people don't know are going to trade. So many agents sit and wait for the right house to come on the MLS — that's not the agent who gets the most done. It's the agent who knows where to look. If you're waiting for your client to text you "this is the one," you're way behind where you should be. My job is to be looking at every house as it hits and pinging you — "what about this, what about that" — because every data point matters, for me and for them.

Every listing matters most in person — you can rule a house out from a photo or video, but you have to go see it, feel it, listen to the neighborhood, see the neighbors.

Why professional photography and the cover photo matter

Matthew Gluck

You just brought up the listing side — what do you think is the most important thing when you're getting ready to market a home? What brings people in, or scares them off?

Jamie Fosgate

We've kind of built this company on one premise: it has to look fantastic in photos and video. About 98% of people look online before they buy a house, and if you don't have the proper photos and videos, you'll get swiped past before people even give you a chance. If there's clutter in the photos, you're costing yourself money.

Matthew Gluck

That's what I say to a seller right from the start. There are two things that make people say "I want to see that house" versus "I'm going to skip it," from the jump on Zillow, Trulia, Realtor.com, or the MLS: the cover photo — that thumbnail — and the price. If the photo looks bad, they skip it. If the price is out of whack, they skip it. Nail those two things and you not only increase traffic, you're likely to sell in the first couple of weekends. Nothing is more important than those two. And when buyers want to get in, be available to show — there's nothing worse as a buyer's agent than trying to get into a house that acts like you're trying to get in to see the president.

Are open houses necessary to sell a home?

Jamie Fosgate

Selling your home is inconvenient — you'll have every neighbor who's been curious for ten years wanting to see inside. But you don't need an open house as a seller. The open house mostly helps realtors get new clients. If you're selling, here's the truth: buyers with real intent make an appointment to see you — they're not the ones coming to the open house. They have a pre-approval, a buyer's agent, and they're through the door on the first or second day.

Matthew Gluck

At a Zillow industry conference, the data showed 40% of the time, the first person through the door is your eventual buyer — someone who's shown intent, usually has a pre-approval or pre-qualification, and almost always has a buyer's agent. When a buyer has a buyer's agent and a pre-approval, you're showing the seller: I'm a serious buyer, take my offer seriously. Looking back at the homes I've sold, the biggest group of buyers were the first people through the door, and the lowest number came from the open house.

What makes NestEdge different

Matthew Gluck

The choice of buyer's agent is key, because so many agents will set up a search, wait for something to pop up on the MLS, unlock the door, and pray. The best buyer's agents are doing multiple things, some in front of your face, some not.

Jamie Fosgate

My best characteristic: I'm not sitting waiting for a property to hit the MLS. I know my peers in town, and if I don't have a listing that fits a client, I'm calling my top peers — "I'm looking for a colonial with a pool, four bedrooms, do you have anything coming, anything off-market?" And over the years I've built equity with those relationships, so when I call somebody, they know they'll have a good interaction with me. A new or less-active agent doesn't have those relationships.

The other thing a novice agent does: show up at the property, fiddle with the lock box, walk around like they're a buyer themselves. The moment I get out of the car, I'm looking at the roof — does it look aged, does it have 20 more years. Clients are looking at bookcases and bedroom sizes; I'm looking for signs of water or mold. You don't need five people touring a house all looking at the same thing — you need somebody with a trained eye giving you value, helping protect you from buying something that's going to hurt you later. A buyer's agent isn't there to sell you the house — only you know if it's right for your family. We've seen thousands of homes, good and bad; our clients have only seen five or ten, and don't know what to look out for.

Matthew Gluck

If you feel your buyer's agent is trying to actively sell you on a home, get rid of them — we're not salespeople, we're in the service business. We help with the search, bring options, help with negotiation, and most importantly protect clients from a poor house, a poor attorney, a poor inspector. The home has to sell itself; people only buy what works for them.

Jamie Fosgate

Before real estate I spent 20 years at Macy's negotiating deals, in the room, spearheading. I think a big part of what separates me is I nail negotiations almost every time — I pretty much know where we need to land to get the house. Winning a best-and-final in Westchester is so often not just about the top number. I'm most interested in what's motivating the seller: is it timing to move out? That conversation has to happen with the listing agent, and you need equity and a track record to get that kind of information. Sometimes it's every last dollar; sometimes it's closing timing, or cash versus mortgage contingency.

One example: I sold a house in Ardsley where we had to agree to move an entire home gym — about 40 massive pieces — out of the basement as part of our offer. We won because of that; other buyers had higher numbers or more money down, but we took on getting that gym out, and I knew that was the seller's sticking point.

Matthew Gluck

Open communication in negotiations fosters better relationships going forward with fellow agents, so nobody feels screwed or marginalized at the end of the process.

Jamie Fosgate

I learned a valuable lesson at Macy's about this — a project manager used to call every losing vendor individually and explain why they weren't chosen. That kind of open communication builds relationships. I had clients in Chappaqua a few years back where we were within about $10,000 of two other bids, and the other agent told me flat out: "We're taking your bid not because of your client or your terms, but because I've worked with you before, and I know you'll get to the closing table and do it fairly." That reputation is why we win deals.

Westchester County real estate market conditions

Matthew Gluck

What's the market like right now in Westchester — all one market, all sellers, all buyers, or a mix?

Jamie Fosgate

It's a mixed bag. Good houses still sell. Westchester isn't Topeka, Kansas — most national real estate news doesn't really apply here or in the broader tri-state/Hudson Valley area. Rates at seven, seven-and-a-quarter, seven-and-a-half certainly play a role, but not nearly the role they might elsewhere. It might slow some things down, but good houses are still turning fast; houses that need work sit a little longer, but move quickly if priced right.

Matthew Gluck

The one product we don't have in Westchester is the mint-condition home — people will always pay a premium for that, in Briarcliff, Croton, Ossining, anywhere. If it's priced right, it goes quickly. Taking a more macro view: the high-dollar towns with big school districts — Chappaqua, Scarsdale, Briarcliff, Armonk, Byram Hills, Pleasantville — remain sellers' markets all the way up to the very high end, because there's no inventory. Outside those towns — Carmel, Mahopac, parts of Bedford, Mount Kisco — it's turned much weaker, closer to equilibrium than it's been the last two or three years.

Jamie Fosgate

It's all relative to Westchester, though — I'm getting clients into homes that are on the market two or three weeks and still getting offers. Historically that's still really fast; a house sitting for three weeks priced right never happened back in 2022.

Matthew Gluck

It's more important now than ever for a seller not to price too high out of the gate. Price at the market, maybe a little below, to drive demand — you'll ultimately sell at a higher price because of competition, and you'll be done sooner. Price too high out of the box in Chappaqua, Armonk, Briarcliff, or Scarsdale and fail to drive traffic in the first month, and the market will punish you — showings stop, and buyers assume something's wrong with the house, when really something's wrong with the pricing. I tell every seller: we want to list at a price where, if we get it, you're good — but it has to be a fair market price, not a wish price. All you need are two buyers who fall in love with the property, and that's when you see those big numbers on Zillow.

Jamie Fosgate

That's why we make a point as listing agents to be at as many showings as we can — if you're not there, how do you know if a buyer's emotionally attached? I'll stay in another room and listen to the conversations buyers are having as they walk through. If a listing agent just puts a lock box on the house and tells the buyer's agent to let them know if there's an offer, they're missing all of that.

Matthew Gluck

On financing: at the very least, a buyer should get a pre-approval before touring — that's you giving the bank information and them giving you a number back. A pre-qualification means the bank has actually vetted your employment, your paycheck, your bank statements. For a seller and a listing agent, a pre-qualification is a big signal that a buyer can actually get to the closing table. If you're a serious buyer, get that done while you're looking — it puts you ahead of other buyers, and it's a lever you can pull yourself.

Jamie Fosgate

Last point for sellers: in key towns we work in — Chappaqua, Briarcliff, Armonk, Pleasantville, Croton — two-thirds of deals happen between January and June. One mistake sellers make is listing in March but photographing the home in January or February, so a beautiful tiered backyard with a pool and sport court is shown covered in snow. If your listing agent is worth their salt, they're photographing the exterior — drones, stills, social media — back in the summer, and sitting on those photos until it's time to list. Sellers should reach out to their agent early, ideally the agent they bought the house with, and say when they're thinking of selling, because you can't go back in time for those photos once the season's passed.

[cut: off-topic aside about the NFL trade deadline]

Matthew Gluck

Great episode one. We'll be back hopefully in another week or so with episode two — we're going to come up with an intro and outro, maybe a branded splash page. We'd like to bring on some of our other agents, talk to vendors in the community we work with, do town spotlights, and talk to specific business owners and residents to get their perspectives on this crazy county — with taxes and everything else going on here. Looking forward to it.

Jamie Fosgate

Thank you, my man. Look forward to the next one.

Work With NestEdge Realty

If you are embarking on a new property journey or simply want to find out how we can help you, give our team members a call.

Follow Me on Instagram