This is one of the most common conversations I have with buyers looking in northern Westchester:
“We like both Chappaqua and Briarcliff Manor — but which one is the better buy right now?”
It’s a smart question. These towns are only minutes apart, yet from a real-estate standpoint, they behave very differently — especially in today’s market.
As someone who lives and works in this area daily and has helped buyers purchase homes in both Chappaqua and Briarcliff Manor, I’ll tell you this upfront:
👉 There is no universal winner — but there is a better choice depending on what you value most.
Let’s break it down the way buyers actually experience it.
1. Home Prices: Chappaqua Commands a Premium
On average, Chappaqua home prices are meaningfully higher than Briarcliff Manor.
Why?
-
Larger lots
-
Higher-end new construction
-
A national reputation driven by schools and long-term demand
-
Strong buyer interest from NYC relocations
Briarcliff Manor, by contrast, often offers:
-
Lower entry prices
-
More homes under key psychological thresholds
-
Better value per dollar spent on square footage
Right now:
If your goal is maximizing house for the money, Briarcliff Manor often wins.
2. Property Taxes: A Critical (and Often Overlooked) Difference
This is where many buyers are surprised.
Two similarly priced homes — one in Chappaqua and one in Briarcliff — can have very different tax profiles, depending on:
-
School district
-
Assessment history
-
Village vs. town location
In many cases, Briarcliff Manor offers:
-
Lower or more predictable taxes
-
Better alignment between purchase price and annual carrying cost
For buyers thinking long-term affordability (not just purchase price), Briarcliff can be the stronger financial play.
3. Schools: Both Excellent — With Different Reputations
Let’s be clear: both school districts are excellent.
-
Chappaqua schools carry a broader national reputation and consistently attract relocating buyers.
-
Briarcliff schools are highly regarded locally and often feel more tight-knit.
From a resale standpoint:
-
Chappaqua’s school reputation adds a premium
-
Briarcliff’s schools deliver strong value without as much pricing inflation
If schools are your top priority, you can’t go wrong in either town — but you may pay more for the Chappaqua name.
4. Inventory & Competition: Very Different Buyer Experiences
Chappaqua:
-
Tighter inventory
-
Faster-moving listings
-
More bidding wars at popular price points
-
Less room for negotiation
Briarcliff Manor:
-
Slightly more flexible inventory
-
Better opportunities to negotiate
-
Fewer “must-overbid” situations
Right now:
Buyers who want leverage, optionality, and less stress often find Briarcliff Manor more forgiving.
5. Commute & Lifestyle
Both towns offer:
-
Metro-North access
-
Easy access to Route 9A and the Taconic
-
Strong community feel
Chappaqua:
-
Larger, more spread-out feel
-
Charming downtown
-
Strong sense of privacy
Briarcliff Manor:
-
More compact
-
Village-style lifestyle
-
Easy access to the Hudson River area and Ossining amenities
This often comes down to personal preference — not value.
So… Which Town Is the Better Buy Right Now?
Here’s my honest, experience-based answer:
Chappaqua may be the better long-term prestige and resale play.
Briarcliff Manor may be the better value and negotiating opportunity today.
If you:
-
Want the strongest brand recognition and don’t mind paying for it → Chappaqua
-
Want more house, better taxes, and less competition → Briarcliff Manor
The “better buy” depends entirely on your goals, timeline, and tolerance for competition.
A Final Thought for Buyers
One of the biggest mistakes I see buyers make is choosing a town first — and a home second.
The smarter approach is to:
-
Compare specific homes
-
Analyze taxes and long-term costs
-
Understand resale dynamics
-
Look at micro-locations within each town
That’s where real value is found.
If you’re actively comparing Chappaqua and Briarcliff Manor and want a side-by-side, property-specific analysis, I’m happy to help you think through it — without pressure.